Monday, June 21, 2010

God's Cosmic Safari Rain Forest Adventure

I've been noticing something odd recently. Churches all over the place are advertising for the various VBS experiences that they are offering for the young people in their communities. That in itself is not odd, but the adventurous names given to the VBS themes are what keep catching my attention. Names like "Safari with God" or "Rain Forest Adventure" or "Galactic Explorers" are marketed by taping handmade signs to the church's roadside display (the same displays that list the pastor's name, service times, and denomination, telling everyone exactly when and how they can access God once a week on Sunday mornings). Some lucky churches may receive thier national denomination's chosen VBS materials in advance, so that they even have some marketing signs to display for all who drive past (as if to say, "The party is in here for this one week this summer!").

This type of thing sends a message that the really adventurous life with God can only be found on adventures with wild animals in Africa or in the rain forest or even in outer space. This plays right into what I call escapist theology. Most Christians in America today live like their own towns and cities are evil, that this whole world is evil, and our only escape is to either become missionaries to the rain forest or hope that we are going to somehow vanish and land magically in heaven to escape everything (the rapture, and escapist theology in general, is not biblical by the way). What's my point? God created everything, and it is GOOD! Even though we live in a present evil age, God does not say that his creation is evil. Christians need to engage culture, especially our own towns and cities every single day throughout the year. God is in cities! Some people think God can only be found in nature by sitting next to waterfalls or frollicking in mountain meadows. Yes, God is found in those places, but he is also to be found in cities and in the midst of broken systems and broken relationships. People are hurting right next door and right down the street from us, not just in the rain forest and on safaris. We should be teaching our children that!

We need to stop teaching our children that life is adventurous with God only one week during the summer of every year. We need to stop teaching our children that the real adenturous life with God only happens in the rain forest. Life is adventurous with God all of the time! Our children should be doing hard things, learning how to engage brokenness in the world, and learning how God is moving every day throughout our own lives and our own culture. Instead, most Christian parents are very actively overprotecting thier children and "providing" for them as stagnant and neutral environments as they can possibly force upon them. We simply must create that all important Christian bubble, which will serve to protect our children from this evil world. Then, we'll let them out of the bubble for one week each year so that they can learn about how an adventure with God is found in outer space. But then it's right back into the bubble after that. Right?

Parents... please, please, please teach your children by both telling and modeling for them that life with God is an adventure all of the time, in our own contexts, in our own communities and schools and workplaces. God is not only to be found and experienced in a church building on Sunday mornings, or for one week each summer. The reason most kids walk away from their Christian faith when they enter college is because their parents helped them develop a very wierd escapist theology which they in turn are unable to contextualize to their new environment on their own. Teach your children how to engage culture, not escape from it. We don't really need to send our kids as missionaries to Africa or the rain forest anymore. Eighty percent of the world's Christians now live outside the West in places like that. That missionary strategy worked! But now, it is not needed anymore. Christianity is rapidly declining in America. Africa is now sending missionaries to us in America! You need to teach your children how to be on fire for God and live the adventurous journey with Christ right here where we are living right now!

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

Bryan

As usual, I concur with your position. Just a few comments:

I realize that churches feel like that have to add some 'zing' to get kids to come to VBS, but it still drives me nuts. When my kids were of that age, they went to VBS because as their parents we wanted them to go, to receive good teaching, etc. Going/not going wasn't even an option.


Second: you don't think the Rapture is Biblical?! You heretic!!!! LOL Actually, as an amillennialist I agree, but I can't believe you haven't gotten a bunch of ranting comments on that.

John V

Anonymous said...

Dang - picking on the kids now. Do you need a good James Bond video game beating?

Finally chiming in on your posts and hoping our friendship is still intact enough that you'll read them... Going to go back to previous posts too - unless I find out that you're bashing Christian puppies... That's more than I can handle.

OK - on this post: Add to the issue that those VBS signs are probably just as much targeted at parents who really are hoping for a well-organized week of childcare. :) Seriously though, kids meals at McD's are targeted probably as much to the kids as to parents... playing on our need to give our children a memorable experience (even if it's just for the 10 minutes it takes to scarf down the junk food so they can play with their new happy meal "toy"). Do a marketing/visual/"prize-at-the-end-AFTER-you-eat-your-apple-slices" comparison between McD's happy meals and most VBS programs. The 1-to-1 comparisons might be a bit ugly.

Still, VBS does have the potential to do what some camps or retreats can do (when they're done well) - that is, focus our attention for longer than a few minutes and hopefully ingrain something worth remembering. For those few hours, the kids are a captive audience, usually in a format that recognizes their need for activity, hands-on exercises, story/narrative, friends, and - most important - snacks. That's not a bad formula to introduce some good content. The question is, of course, what content? Is it worth remembering? Does it transform, even at a child's level? Or, will they just remember the cool safari animals?

On another point you make: that the missionary strategy has worked on foreign fields. While I am the first to agree that we live on a mission field in America (I've been preaching that message since the '90s as you may remember) - I think the jury is out on whether foreign missions has "worked." I have limited experience on this, but from what I've seen - much of what we've seen happen on foreign turf is basically a 1950's version of conversionist/fundamentalist evangelicalism that will possibly just need to be deconstructed in another 20 years or so... That is NOT to minimize the very dedicated and sacrificial work being done by missionaries in very challenging parts of the world. I don't want to be seen as saying THAT. However, most of the theology I see being taken over seas looks an awful lot like what I see you (rightly) challenging here in the states.

So - is their a high percentage of people claiming Christianity in foreign countries? Of course. But what "kind" of Christianity are we talking about? I think that's too-be-determined.

All that said: There are incredible theologies being born out of their original foreign contexts - not transplanted in by western missionaries. Are those theological voices heard and validated?

Ok, diving deeper into your earlier posts now...

- Tim

Bryan McCabe said...

Thanks for the comments, Tim. Yeah, Julie read this VBS blog post and she graciously informed me that where ever the line is for me expressing my opinions in public forum... I probably just crossed it. I believe she said, "So now you're picking on children?" Point taken.

I'll try to stay away from bashing Christian puppies. Also, I had a good blog post brewing in my mind about churches that "pay" kids to memorize individual Bible verses. I don't think that one's going to make the cut now.

I understand your point about the type of Chrisianity abroad... I made a pretty big generalization with that comment about the mission being accomplished.

Bryan McCabe said...

John... I think once I get through my two big DMin projects over the next few weeks I'm going to spend some time writing about the damage that the dispensationalists are causing and I'll present some eschatological perspectives that I believe are more biblically based. Maybe I'll get some more outraged comments then...

Anonymous said...

Bryan

Hooo boy... I can't wait!!!! I love it when there's another radical out there besides me!!!

John V

Jason said...

Bryan, don't worry b/c I don't think you are picking on the kids as much as their parents. I personally don't mind the zing that church provide to get kids into the door. Of course I completely agree that it needs to continue once they walk out that door too. If some crazy african safari gets a kid excited to go to church and learn about Jesus that I'm all for it. I think in modern time churches need to step it up and to get people in the door as long as it's done ethically and with Christ at the center, not increasing the weekly tithe amount.